AI & Automation
When my B2B SaaS client asked me to revamp their newsletter strategy, I expected the usual challenge of improving open rates. What I got instead was a masterclass in why most SaaS newsletters fail to drive actual business results.
Their previous newsletter looked impressive – sleek design, feature announcements, industry news roundups. The metrics seemed decent too: 18% open rate, 2.1% click-through rate. But here's what nobody was tracking: zero conversions from trial to paid subscriptions could be attributed to their newsletter content.
After 6 months of testing different content approaches, I discovered something that contradicts everything most SaaS companies believe about newsletter marketing. The content that performed best had nothing to do with product updates or industry insights. Instead, it was deeply personal, authentic storytelling that treated the newsletter less like a company announcement and more like a founder's direct conversation with users.
Here's what you'll learn from my experience:
This isn't another guide about email design or subject line optimization. This is about the fundamental shift in content approach that turns newsletters from company spam into genuine relationship-building tools that drive business results. Check out our other SaaS growth strategies that complement this newsletter approach.
Walk into any SaaS marketing meeting and you'll hear the same newsletter content recommendations repeated like gospel. Product updates, feature releases, customer success stories, industry insights, and educational content. This is what every marketing blog, every agency, and every "growth expert" will tell you to include in your SaaS newsletter.
The conventional wisdom makes logical sense on paper. After all, you're running a software company, so naturally your newsletter should focus on:
This approach exists because it feels safe and professional. It's what successful companies like HubSpot and Salesforce do in their newsletters. It aligns with traditional B2B marketing best practices. Most importantly, it's easy to delegate to a content marketing team – you don't need the founder's personal involvement to create this type of content.
But here's where conventional wisdom falls short: SaaS newsletters aren't competing against other SaaS newsletters. They're competing against every other email in your subscriber's inbox. When your newsletter reads like corporate marketing material, it gets skipped just like every other promotional email. The "professional" tone that feels appropriate for B2B actually makes your content forgettable and disposable.
Most SaaS companies optimize for the wrong metrics – open rates and click-through rates – without connecting newsletter performance to actual business outcomes like trial conversions, upgrade rates, or customer retention. This disconnect means they keep producing content that looks successful in email dashboards but doesn't move the business forward.
Who am I
7 years of freelance experience working with SaaS
and Ecommerce brands.
When I started analyzing my client's newsletter performance, the data told a clear story: their corporate-style content was achieving industry-standard metrics but driving zero business impact. The newsletter felt like an afterthought – something the marketing team produced because "every SaaS should have a newsletter."
My client was a B2B SaaS founder who had built a solid product but struggled with trial-to-paid conversions. Their newsletter went to 3,500 subscribers, mostly trial users and prospects from their content marketing efforts. Despite decent engagement numbers, we couldn't trace a single paid conversion back to newsletter content over the previous six months.
This discovery coincided with something else I'd been observing: the founder's personal LinkedIn content was actually driving meaningful business results. When he shared behind-the-scenes stories about building the company, honest reflections on startup challenges, or personal takes on industry trends, these posts generated genuine engagement and converted followers into trial users.
The contrast was striking. His LinkedIn posts felt authentic and human – like getting insights from someone you'd actually want to grab coffee with. The company newsletter felt like corporate communications – professionally written but completely forgettable. The founder's personal content built trust and connection. The newsletter just took up inbox space.
That's when I realized we were approaching newsletter content completely backwards. Instead of trying to make the newsletter more "professional," we needed to make it more personal. Instead of company updates, we needed founder insights. Instead of product announcements, we needed honest startup stories.
The challenge was convincing my client to bring his authentic voice – the same voice that worked so well on LinkedIn – into the company newsletter. Most founders resist this because it feels "unprofessional" or worry about mixing personal brand with company communications. But that resistance is exactly what keeps most SaaS newsletters trapped in mediocrity.
My experiments
What I ended up doing and the results.
The breakthrough came when I convinced my client to treat the newsletter exactly like his successful LinkedIn posts. Instead of delegating content creation to the marketing team, he started writing every newsletter personally. The format became simple: "What I actually did this week, what I learned from it, and what that means for you."
Here's the specific content approach that transformed their newsletter:
1. Real Work Documentation
Instead of generic "productivity tips," he shared specific challenges he faced that week. When they struggled with a technical integration, he wrote about the exact problem, what they tried, and what finally worked. When a customer churned, he shared the honest post-mortem and lessons learned. This wasn't polished content – it was real documentation of building a business.
2. Behind-the-Scenes Decision Making
Rather than just announcing new features, he explained the reasoning behind product decisions. He shared the customer feedback that led to changes, the internal debates about prioritization, and sometimes the decisions that didn't work out as planned. Subscribers got to see how a SaaS business actually operates, not just its public-facing results.
3. Personal Struggles and Wins
The most engaging content came from his honest reflections on founder challenges. The week he almost gave up, how he handled a difficult team conversation, or celebrating small milestones that wouldn't make it into official company announcements. This personal vulnerability created genuine connection with subscribers.
4. Industry Takes and Contrarian Views
Instead of regurgitating industry news, he shared his personal reactions to trends affecting their market. These weren't neutral summaries – they were opinionated takes that sparked conversation and positioned him as someone worth listening to, not just another SaaS marketer.
The implementation was straightforward but required discipline. Every Friday, he'd spend 30 minutes documenting the week – what happened, what he learned, what surprised him. This became the foundation for each newsletter. No editorial calendar, no content planning sessions, just authentic weekly reflections that provided real value to subscribers.
We also implemented a simple tracking system to connect newsletter engagement to business outcomes. Every newsletter included specific calls-to-action tied to trial upgrades, feature adoption, or customer feedback. This allowed us to measure actual business impact, not just email metrics.
The results spoke clearly about what SaaS subscribers actually want from newsletters. Within three months of switching to personal, founder-led content, we saw dramatic improvements across metrics that actually matter for business growth.
Trial-to-paid conversions increased by 240% for users who actively engaged with newsletters compared to those who didn't. More importantly, we could now directly attribute conversions to specific newsletter content – something that had never happened with their previous corporate-style approach.
Newsletter open rates improved from 18% to 31%, but more significantly, the average time spent reading increased from under 30 seconds to over 3 minutes. Subscribers started replying to newsletters with their own stories, questions, and business challenges. The newsletter became a two-way conversation rather than one-way broadcasting.
Perhaps most importantly, the founder reported that writing the newsletter actually helped him process and improve his own decision-making. The weekly reflection practice forced him to think more deliberately about lessons learned and strategic direction. The newsletter became a business development tool for the company, not just a marketing channel.
Learnings
Sharing so you don't make them.
The biggest lesson from this experiment: SaaS newsletters succeed when they feel less like company communications and more like personal updates from someone you trust. Subscribers don't need another source of industry news or product announcements – they need authentic insights from people who are solving similar problems.
The approach works best for SaaS companies where the founder is actively involved and willing to share authentically. It's less effective for larger companies where leadership is removed from day-to-day operations or for founders who prefer to maintain complete separation between personal and company communications.
My playbook, condensed for your use case.
For SaaS companies looking to implement this approach:
For ecommerce brands adapting this framework:
What I've learned
© Complice.work. 2025.
© Skyward Studio. Built by Nikolai Bain.
Powered by Webflow.
